U.S. better at immigration law
- Font Size:
- Default font size
- Larger font size
By Ruben Navarrette | Monday, May 05, 2008 |
SAN DIEGO — The United States does a better job with immigration than any other country in the world. That’s right, even with its broken border, missed messages, recurring xenophobia and all the shouting on talk shows, other nations — particularly in Europe — are far worse in their treatment of immigrants.
Some, including Rep. Brian Bilbray, R-Calif., would have us follow the lead of countries such as Germany and make it more difficult for children of the foreign-born to obtain citizenship. It’s a dreadful idea. It creates a population alienated from the mainstream and, by depriving them of citizenship rights, makes it easier for them to be preyed upon.
What’s going on in France under new President Nicolas Sarkozy isn’t much better. Patrick Weil, a senior fellow at the French National Research Center in Paris and an expert on French immigration and national identity, said Sarkozy’s “obsession is to reduce the flow of immigrants coming legally from North Africa and Africa,” said Weil, a critic of the French president. As Sarkozy sees it, according to Weil, France is taking in the wrong immigrants from the wrong
countries.
We hear the same complaint here in the United States.
Sarkozy maintains his bias against the Africans, Weil said, “despite the fact that all the comparative studies that have been done show that France is very successful — much more so than other European countries — in the cultural integration of each group of migrants.”
Weil noted that Sarkozy in recent speeches has even spelled out what he calls “the tragedy of Africa” — that the African man has “never really entered into history (nor) really launched himself into the future.”
Obviously, that’s ridiculous. It could also be called racist.
Sarkozy jumped back into the immigration debate last week when he announced that he opposed a blanket amnesty for illegal immigrants even while, in the same breath, acknowledging that the French economy needs foreign workers. It seems there are — to borrow a phrase — jobs the French won’t do.
Nevertheless, Sarkozy has vowed to deport 25,000 illegal immigrants per year. And he wants to make immigration a top priority of the European Union when he takes over its presidency in July. He even created a special ministry for immigration and national identity, making France one of the few countries in the world to have the equivalent of an immigration czar.
Yet one of Sarkozy’s most ambitious ideas could be his worst: national origin quotas to allow for the selection of immigrants from specific geographic areas so as to limit those from certain parts of the world (read: Africa).
That sounds familiar. Country quotas were once a staple of U.S. immigration policy. In the 1920s, Congress caved in to prejudice and created a quota system to limit the number of immigrants from “Southern Europe” (read: Italy). That historical wrong was righted in 1965 when Congress scrapped the quota system in favor of a policy emphasizing family reunification.
But the complaints haven’t gone away, even if they are now limited largely to the rants of cable news demagogues.
Caving in to its own form of demagoguery, France is poised to make the same mistake that the United States did at the beginning of the 20th century.
What sense does that make? Instead of replicating what the United States has done wrong in shaping immigration policy, France would be better off trying to emulate the many things we got right.
Contact Ruben Navarrette at ruben.navarrette@uniontrib.com.
del.icio.us
Digg
NewsVine
Fark
redditMore Stories By Ruben Navarrette
» More Columnists Stories
Highest Rated Articles from the last 7 Days
- Aba Health Insurance?
- Get Discount Health Insurance Quotes - Plans from $19 / Month.
- AbaHealthInsurance.Deal0.com
- ABA Software
- Seven Steps to reading for visual learners and children with autism. An ABA basesd software to teach reading skills.
- www.computhera.com
- Photos and Software for Aba Programs
- Use our photo CDs and interactive software to supplement your Aba therapy programs. All of our software is distraction free and designed to help autistic children learn.
- www.silverliningmm.com
- Ads by Yahoo!
